TDOR: Ending gender based violence against transgender & gender diverse persons in malaysia

Today, on transgender day of remembrance (TDOR), we remember transgender and gender diverse persons who have died due to gender based violence and hate. Transgender and gender diverse persons are disproportionately vulnerable to gender based violence due to multiple factors, including lack of protection, recognition of transgender persons and gender diverse populations, access to information regarding gender identity, among other factors.

Globally, between October 2017 and September, a total of 2018,369 trans and gender-diverse people were reportedly killed. This is an increase of 44 cases compared to last year’s reported numbers cases. This brings to a total of 2,982 trans and gender diverse people of cases of murder reported in 72 countries between January 2008 and September 2018.

However, these are only the reported numbers. Many cases are not reported or misreported. Case in point, the murder trial of a trans woman involving two Chilean tourists that concluded recently on 2 November 2018. Media reports of the trial show that the victim, a trans woman was misgendered throughout the trial. When trans people are misgendered (use of wrong gender markers), it not only strips away trans people’s dignity and right to self-determination, but it also makes it challenging to document and collate cases of crimes against trans people.

In Malaysia, between 2007 and November 2018, at least 14 cases of murder involving trans women as victims were reported. The most recent case reported was in November this year, where a trans woman was allegedly murdered by her partner. The perpetrator has been charged with murder and awaits trial early next year. He was not represented by a lawyer.

While some these cases are investigated, often they are not classified and analyzed correctly using a gender and rights based lens. They are seen, as isolated cases, which result in lack of specific interventions or solutions to the gender-based violence, hate crimes and transphobia experienced by trans people. Consequently, these experiences of violence and crimes by trans people remain invisible, become prolonged and cyclic.

According to the facts of the recent case, an altercation between the perpetrator and victim occurred concerning jealousy and money related issues, which escalated to the death of the woman after the perpetrator, strangled her. Similar cases involving trans women have been documented and reported in the past. In 2016, a trans woman was found murdered after an altercation with allegedly her boyfriend.

Rising hate crime and speech

Hate crimes and speech towards transgender people online and offline are on the rise and correlate. The increase of hateful and discriminatory speech in Malaysia emboldens the perpetrators and vigilante groups to carry out acts of violence against transgender persons with impunity.

In August 2018, a trans woman in Negeri Sembilan was assaulted by a group of men, including youths, resulting in serious injuries, including broken ribs and a ruptured spleen. Justice for Sisters also received complaints of harassment of trans women by vigilante groups in Kedah. While these are enough to ring alarm bells, we believe there are many other cases of hate crimes.

Recent trends to of boycotts and protest against transgender women entrepreneurs on social media are also a point of concern. In October 2018, a few trans women entrepreneurs were prevented from participating in an expo in Perak due to protest by local groups. This further demonstrates the shrinking spaces and the escalation of violence towards trans people.

TDOR reminds us of the impact of marginalization and multiple forms of oppression that trans and gender-diverse people face daily. Together we can change this situation and dismantle oppression. Together we are in solidarity with trans and gender diverse people everywhere resisting and dismantling oppression.

Advertisements

Transgender Day of Remembrance 2017

Remembering the violence, hate crime and murder of trans people and gender diverse persons based on gender identity and gender expression

On 20th November, Transgender Day of Remembrance (TDOR) we remember all the trans people and gender diverse people who have been subjected to murder and violence based on gender identity and gender expression. On TDOR, we remember and honour their lives, and we continue to seek justice and end violence against trans and gender diverse people based on gender identity and gender expression.

According to updates by the Transgender Europe (TGEU), 325 cases of murder of trans and gender diverse persons were reported between October 2016 and September 2017. This year’s update shows an increase of 30 cases from last year.

In total between January 2008 and September 2017, a total of 2,609 trans and gender diverse people were reported killed in 71 countries. Out of the total reported cases, 231 reported cases come from Asia.

In Malaysia, 3 cases of murder of trans women were reported in 2017. Two out of the three cases were reported in the media, and the trans women were subjected to misgendering or the use of wrong gender pronouns, terms or labels, description and name in the media. In addition, the outcomes of the investigation of these cases have yet to be seen.

February 2017 – Sameera Krishnan was brutally attacked, shot, tortured, mutilated and found dead in Pahang. Her case was reportedly investigated by the police. However, outcomes of the case are unknown.

May 2017 – An unnamed trans woman was found dead in her bedroom with both wrists bound with wirehair dryers and cable mobile phone charger in Kuala Lumpur. The body was found approximately 4 days after death due to the smell from decay.

August 2017 – A 22-year-old trans woman was reportedly murdered in Kuala Lumpur. This case did not appear in the media.

We also remember and highlight the case of a Thai trans woman in Penang in May 2017. The woman who is also a sex worker, sustained severe injuries and was almost killed due to multiple stabbing with a knife by a client over allegedly expensive rates.

Between 2007 and 2016, at least 10 cases of murder have been reported in the media. In these 10 cases, the trans women were subjected to brutal violence, including being beaten to death with a hammer, strangled, gagged, stabbed multiple times, physically assaulted, pushed from a building, drowned in a water retention pond, etc.

Its important to note that these are reported cases of murder, hate crime and violence. There are many cases of hate crime, murder and violence that go unreported (due to fear of reprisal or further violence, lack of trust in law enforcement agencies to investigate cases, lack of serious and meaningful investigation of cases, lack of friendly and inclusive reporting mechanism, among others), unnoticed (due to misgendering in the media among others) and silenced (due to shame by family members, fear of media sensationalization, among others).

The violence experienced by trans and gender diverse people do not happen in a vacuum, and it correlates with the broader discriminatory laws, policies, misinformation regarding gender identity and trans people, lack of positive and affirming representation in the media among many other factors. Criminalization of trans people increases barriers for trans people to access justice and continues to marginalize trans people. In addition, the lack of inclusive, sensitive and friendly redress mechanisms further limit access to justice for trans and gender diverse persons.

We believe that the marginalization and violence against trans and gender diverse persons must end, and we can end it together. We call everyone to light a candle for all trans and gender diverse people have been subjected to murder and hate crime this 20th November.

Resources:

For more information regarding TDOR, please visit

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWnWV6VCNm4

http://tdor.tgeu.org/

http://transrespect.org/en/tmm-update-trans-day-remembrance-2017/

Name list of trans and gender diverse people who have been subjected to murder

http://transrespect.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/TvT_TMM_TDoR2017_Namelist_EN.pdf

Media kit for journalist

https://www.glaad.org/publications/tdorkit

For updates in Malaysia, please visit justiceforsisters.wordpress.com

Downloadables

https://justiceforsisters.wordpress.com/2015/11/18/200/

Reported murder of trans people in Malaysia

In conjunction with trans awareness month and TDOR this November 2017 Justice for Sisters in collaboration with the G-Blog bring you articles and stories by trans people